The pen-drop thief!? First-time NTR! Birth of the slutty neighbor! Just as I was about to have my first experience with my newly made girlfriend... the sister living next door took my virginity and milked me for cum, over and over. Huh…? My first time wasn't with her but with the neighbor?! “You’re going to have sex with your girlfriend, right? Is it tomorrow?” I might not have any cum left for her!!
